It has no plot. It
contains no intensive research. There are no recorded conversations of those
who knew her or worked with her or loved her. And yet for all that, the
Christie’s catalog of Marilyn’s personal property may very well be the most
intimate look any of us will ever have of this special woman, this 20th
century icon and synonym for American culture.
The auction took
place going on six years ago. Other auctions have come and gone. Items appear
on a near daily basis on eBay, touting assurances that they were once worn or
owned by her. And yet the Christie’s two day auction, (October 27 and 28,
1999), has reached legendary status-- those of us not lucky enough to have
attend hanging on every word of those who did, listening and imagining what
they were able to witness with their very own eyes with nearly the same envy if
they had actually been in Madison Square Garden on May 17, 1962 to see Marilyn
transform “Happy Birthday” for all time.
The word
“obsessed” has such negative connotations and yet I guess when it comes to
Marilyn, I would have to say that it applies to me-- the only comfort comes in
knowing that I am not alone. For if there were not hundreds of thousands, maybe
millions of others as “obsessed”, a catalog of her personal belongings would
never have been offered outside of the auction itself. But even for one
“obsessed”, there are certain times when reading about her, when peering over
the gate of her last home, of standing at her crypt, that a sneaking feeling of
guilt comes over me, guilt at prying, of wanting to know every detail of every
conversation she ever held, of every personal relationship she enjoyed, of
every thought that had gone through her head in those all too brief thirty-six
years. And yet, I don’t think I have ever felt as guilty as I did the first
time I got this book home to myself and sat down to slowly savor every page.
For really, what
is this book other than the cataloging of items left behind by the dead? If you
are fortunate enough to have never experienced the task of going through the
belongings left behind by a deceased loved one, purchasing the Christie’s
catalog will likely present you with the same overwhelming emotions of going
through a family member’s collected objects, items gathered throughout a
lifetime, items held onto long after their worth has passed, items saved for
sentimental and practical reasons. A letter from an ex. Ticket stubs to a
forgotten play. Bedroom slippers. Worn out slips. Half-used tubes of lipstick.
The first read
through is rough. Somewhere between the “JFK Birthday Dress” and the chipped,
pink makeup case, it dawns on you that this is not just a bunch of stuff that
Marilyn herself actually owned-- these are the belongings of a woman who once
really was alive, once really did walk around, breathe, laugh, got bored, got
excited and, like every single one of us will one day do, died. Funny how I can
watch Marilyn Monroe movies, look at pictures of her every day, read about her,
talk about her, and yet flipping through the Christie’s catalog it still struck
me full force that this was a woman who was once very much alive and now was
very much dead. Even though I can remember Marilyn Monroe the Movie Star, can
remember when I first heard of her passing, looking at the physical items she
left behind brought home her life and her death as nothing else ever has.
Would I have
preferred that Lee Strasberg had carried out Marilyn’s wishes and distributed
her belongings among her friends? Out of respect for Marilyn’s wishes, of
course I do. What was it that made him not carry those wishes out, made him
procrastinate so long that Marilyn’s personal property ended up in the hands of
a woman she had never met? Knowing men who lost partners back in the late
eighties who have yet to throw out the deceased’s old sweat shirts and Stephen
King books, I think Lee’s not wanting to actually finalize Marilyn’s death by
distributing her possessions is only human. So yes, I do wish that he had
followed through and while I understand how something like that can be put off
and put off until it is too late, in a sense I am grateful that he did. If
Marilyn’s things had been handed out to those she knew and loved, there would
be no Christie’s catalog. And all the items in there that I have come to love
so very much-- like the battered pots and pans, the old magazines, some of the
truly God Awful portraits painted by fans-- I would never have been able to see
them for you and I both know that no matter how her friends loved her, no one
was going to want to have her old vegetable steamer.
Would Marilyn have
been surprised that thirty-seven years after her death these items would have
ended up on the auctioneer’s block? I’d bet she would and I also would bet that
for most of the things that were sold over those two days, she’d have gotten a
royal kick out of it. Some of it, I am equally sure, she would never have
wanted anyone to own. Even when she asked Lee to distribute her belongings, I
doubt she meant her bustiers. Some of it, I am sure, would have broken her
heart to see go to people she did not know-- the stone female torso that Arthur
had given her. Her framed photos of Eleanor Duse.
Like the
Jacqueline Onassis and Marlon Brando auctions, Marilyn Monroe’s personal
property being offered to the highest bidder is somewhat of a new phenomenon. I
think it’s great that items you or I would love to actually own are now out
there. Of course, unless you’ve at least as much money as God, there’s not much
chance you’ll actually own any of these things -- still, it’s nice to know that
there is the possibility. I would have preferred that all of it had been
donated somehow and kept intact, for installation at a Marilyn Monroe Museum.
But, like so many dreams, I doubt if that will ever come true. In the meantime,
I have the catalog.
One last thought
and that is that looking through the physical items left behind by the dead
brings that person’s life into such sharp focus. By leafing through the
Christie’s catalog, I learned more about Marilyn’s own personal style in home
decoration, her taste in literature, her person fashion preferences and, (and
this is where the feeling of voyeurism comes back), just how sentimental a
woman she was. Holding onto the ring that Joe gave her. Holding onto an
autographed baseball. Holding onto those pretty bad oil paintings fans had made
for her. Sometimes you can learn more about a person by what they hold onto
than what they discard. For this, I am grateful to Lee for never quite getting
around to disbursing Marilyn’s possessions. It allowed me the chance to learn
just a little more about her and how can I not be grateful for that?